"Miracle Broth" vs. the price tag
La Mer
Skincare · Sourced from r/SkincareAddiction + X
58
Consensus score
🧠 The Reddit Consensus
Reddit is overwhelmingly skeptical of La Mer: a widely-shared teardown pegs production at roughly $35 a tub, commenters call it "overpriced petroleum," mock the "Miracle Broth" branding, and balk at ~$150 for half an ounce — repeatedly floating Nivea and Eucerin as near-dupes. A minority of long-term users genuinely love the rich texture and ritual and say it's worth it to them, and on X the brand mostly surfaces as aspirational, with viral "affordable La Mer" comparisons.
Key takeaways
- La Mer is controversial sentiment across 5 analyzed r/SkincareAddiction threads.
- Community consensus score: 58/100, derived from 51 real owner comments.
- Best suited for: Wealthy buyers who value the sensory ritual and prestige and have dry skin — but the community's consistent advice is that far cheaper moisturizers perform comparably.
Top 3 Pros
✅ Luxurious texture and ritual
Loyalists love the experience — the cream feels rich and indulgent, and some long-term users say their skin does well on it.
✅ Effective rich occlusive for very dry skin
As a heavy moisturizer it can genuinely comfort dry skin — which is also why basic occlusives like Nivea get floated as dupes.
✅ Prestige and gifting appeal
The brand cachet is real; for some buyers the status and packaging are part of what they're paying for.
Top 3 Cons
⚠️ Wildly overpriced vs. cost
"$150 for 0.5oz 💀" — a popular video claims ~$35 to produce a tub; the markup is the community's #1 complaint.
⚠️ "Miracle Broth" is marketing
Commenters argue it performs like a basic moisturizer — "overpriced petroleum" — with Nivea/Eucerin rivaling it for a fraction of the price.
⚠️ Underwhelms many
Plenty report it "didn't do anything," and note the antioxidants likely degrade in the jar packaging.
Best suited for
Wealthy buyers who value the sensory ritual and prestige and have dry skin — but the community's consistent advice is that far cheaper moisturizers perform comparably.
Ready to try La Mer?
Compare live prices and availability before you buy.
Source discussions
Every verdict above is grounded in these public r/SkincareAddiction + X sources. Verify any claim yourself.
- r/[misc] Update: I've been using La Mer Crème de La Mer▲ 78412 comments
- r/[MISC] La Mer Soft Cream Price 15ml Canada ($156 CAD)▲ 11912 comments
- r/[MISC] It costs $35 to produce 1 tub of Creme de La Mer — plus other tidbits▲ 112 comments
- 𝕏Curse the person who put me on to the La Mer face cream… (X)▲ 20511engagement
More skincare verdicts
Informational summary of public Reddit discussion · not veterinary advice · PetConsensus